Why is My Preschooler Stealing? Understanding and Addressing Kleptomania in Young Children

Not medical advice. For emergencies, call your local emergency number.

It’s a distressing situation when a young child repeatedly steals from their preschool, as it can impact their schooling and future development. This article aims to explore the potential reasons behind a 4- or 5-year-old’s stealing behavior and offer guidance for parents.

Understanding the Behavior:

At this age, stealing is rarely about malicious intent or a conscious understanding of right and wrong in the adult sense. Instead, it can stem from several factors:

Impulse Control: Young children are still developing impulse control. They might see something they want and take it without fully grasping the consequences or the concept of ownership.
Attention Seeking: A ‘wild child’ or a child experiencing shifts in family dynamics (like a new sibling) might act out to get attention, even negative attention.
Testing Boundaries: Children are natural explorers and rule-benders. Stealing might be a way to test the limits of what they can get away with and how adults react.
Lack of Understanding Ownership: While they understand ‘mine,’ the concept of ‘yours’ and ‘not yours’ can be complex for preschoolers. They might not fully grasp that items in class belong to others or the school.
Developmental Stage: Some behaviors, while concerning, can be part of normal developmental phases that require patience and guidance.

Strategies for Parents:

Since traditional discipline methods like grounding or taking away electronics haven’t been fully effective, consider these approaches:

Consistent and Immediate Correction: When an incident occurs, address it calmly but firmly. The key is immediate response.
Focus on Empathy and Understanding: Instead of solely focusing on punishment, help your child understand why it’s wrong. “When you take [item], [classmate’s name] feels sad because they wanted to play with it. How would you feel if someone took your toy?”
Teach About Ownership and Sharing: Clearly explain that things in school belong to the school, other children, or the teacher. Practice asking before taking. Emphasize sharing and taking turns.
Positive Reinforcement: Catch your child doing something good. Praise them specifically for asking permission, sharing, or being honest. “I’m so proud of you for asking before you took that crayon!”
Dedicated One-on-One Time: Acknowledge that this is challenging with a new baby. Even short, focused 10-15 minute periods of undivided attention daily can make a difference. Let her choose the activity.
Collaborate with Teachers: Schedule that sit-down meeting. Share your concerns and what you’re trying at home. Ask for their observations: when does it happen? What triggers it? What strategies have they found effective in the classroom?
Explore Underlying Needs: Is she bored? Seeking attention? Feeling insecure with the new sibling? Sometimes, addressing the root emotional need can reduce the problematic behavior.
Natural and Logical Consequences: Returning the item immediately, apologizing sincerely (and role-playing how to do it), and potentially writing a note or drawing a picture for the person affected can be more impactful than general punishment.

When to Seek Professional Help:

If the behavior persists despite consistent efforts, or if you notice other concerning behaviors (extreme anxiety, aggression, withdrawal), consider consulting with a child psychologist or therapist. They can offer more specialized strategies tailored to your child’s unique needs and help rule out any underlying issues.

Addressing stealing in preschoolers requires patience, consistency, and a focus on teaching empathy and understanding. By working with her school and employing a multi-faceted approach, you can help your child navigate this challenging phase.

Related Guides