Navigating the 'Dada Tax': Understanding Baby's Preference and Your Role as a New Father

Not medical advice. For emergencies, call your local emergency number.

It’s a common, yet often unspoken, challenge new fathers face: the ‘rejection’ from their baby, especially when Mom is around. Many new dads experience a deep sense of hurt and self-doubt when their little one prefers their mother, struggles to settle with them, and fusses uncontrollably in their arms. This post from Reddit’s r/NewParents highlights this very real struggle, describing a 3-month-old who only feels comfortable with her dad in specific contexts and screams bloody murder if her mom isn’t present. The father expresses feeling inadequate, questioning his ability to be a good dad, and how this affects his self-worth. He also touches on the difficulty of giving his wife a break when the baby’s distress escalates with him.

This phenomenon, sometimes affectionately (or not so affectionately) termed the ‘Dada Tax’ or ‘Mom’s Shadow,’ is incredibly normal, particularly in the early months. Babies, especially newborns and young infants, often have a primary attachment figure. This is frequently the mother, due to the biological and emotional bonding during pregnancy and early feeding. This doesn’t diminish your importance or love; it simply reflects the baby’s current stage of development and their primary source of comfort and security.

If you’re experiencing this, know that you are not alone and it doesn’t mean you’re failing as a father. Here’s what to consider:

Your feelings are valid, and it’s commendable that you’re seeking to understand and navigate this phase. With patience, persistence, and a focus on building your unique connection, you will find your rhythm and your baby will increasingly feel secure and loved by you, not just in specific contexts, but in all of them.

Related Guides