Navigating Mixed Signals: Why Your Child Might Act Differently with Each Parent

Not medical advice. For emergencies, call your local emergency number.

It’s common for children to express strong feelings for one parent while exhibiting confusing behaviors when interacting with the other, especially after a separation. The post highlights a parent’s concern about their children (4 and 2 years old) who express missing their dad intensely during their time with the mother but then act distant or annoyed when he calls. This behavior, while perplexing, is not unusual and can stem from several factors.

Understanding the Dynamics:

Expressing Loyalty and Affection: Children often want to please both parents. When they are with the mother and miss the father, expressing this desire loudly is a way of showing love and maintaining their connection. It might also be a subconscious way to reassure themselves that they are not choosing one parent over the other.
Separation Anxiety and Adjustment: Even after 1.5 years, children are still adjusting to the new family dynamic. The every-other-weekend visitation means significant time apart. The intensity of missing the dad when they are with the mom could be a manifestation of their longing.
Behavioral Differences in Different Environments: Children can behave differently in different settings. The home environment with the mother might be their comfort zone, where they feel secure enough to express their emotions freely, including negative ones. When it’s time to talk to the father, it might feel like an obligation or a disruption, leading to resistance.
Four-Year-Old’s Cognitive Development: A 4-year-old’s understanding of relationships and emotions is developing. They may struggle to articulate their feelings clearly. The annoyance or resistance during FaceTime calls could be a mix of tiredness, distraction, or even a subtle way of asserting control in a situation where they have little. They might feel pressured to perform or express a certain level of enthusiasm they don’t genuinely feel at that exact moment.
Two-Year-Old’s Distractibility: A 2-year-old’s attention span is naturally short. They are easily drawn to immediate stimuli and may not understand the importance of a lengthy phone conversation.
The ‘Grass is Greener’ Effect: When children are away from a parent, they might idealize them or express a stronger desire to be with them. Conversely, when it’s time for contact, the reality of the situation (e.g., being interrupted from play) can lead to negative reactions.

What the Parent is Doing Right:

The parent’s approach of never discouraging the children’s love for their dad, affirming that he will call soon, and not speaking ill of him is commendable. It fosters a healthy environment where children feel safe to love both parents.

What to Consider:

Communication with the Father: Gently discussing these observations with the father might be helpful. He might have insights into the children’s behavior during their calls or notice similar patterns.
Reducing Pressure: For the FaceTime calls, perhaps reducing the expectation for lengthy, enthusiastic conversations could help. Shorter, more focused interactions might be more productive.
Consistency and Routine: Maintaining a consistent routine for calls can help children adjust and know what to expect.
Positive Reinforcement: When the children do engage positively, acknowledging it can be beneficial.

It’s crucial to remember that children’s behavior is often a reflection of their internal state and their attempts to navigate complex family dynamics. While confusing, these mixed signals are part of the process of adaptation.

Related Guides